Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

Link to: "Researchers chart rising inequality across millennia"

This link is too good to pass up, especially as our Republican Congress debates lowering taxes for the wealthy.

"Researchers chart rising inequality across millennia


Findings have profound implications for contemporary society"

https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2017-11/wsu-rcr110917.php


One paragraph: "Their findings, published this week in the journal Nature, have profound implications for contemporary society, as inequality repeatedly leads to social disruption, even collapse, said Tim Kohler, lead author and Regents professor of archaeology and evolutionary anthropology at Washington State University. The United States, he noted, currently has one of the highest levels of inequality in the history of the world."

Friday, June 30, 2017

Obligations of the Wealthy

What obligations do capitalists have to their society? Any? Or is it only the money?

Consider somebody who works for a living. Family. Wife and children. Hard worker. Maybe overtime. He has time and resources to look after his own affairs. But does he have time to look at the bigger picture? And even if he had the time, would he have the opportunity. Would he have the education?

Probably not. Indeed, in most cases, a person cannot look after larger interests than his own. Yet, each person is as dependent on this bigger picture as he is of his job. Indeed, one of the people he is most dependent on is his boss. His boss can make his job miserable or pleasant. He can fire him, in some places without any cause at all. Just so, his boss is dependent on his own boss, and his boss on his boss. And so on, up to the very wealthy and very powerful. And even the self employed, even the small business owner is dependent on those richer and more powerful than he is in society. After all, they are able to spend vast sums of money, and alter the government and the allocation of resources. Any one of these powerful could destroy him, the worker, the self employed, the small business man, purely incidentally, without thought, or regard. One has only to look at the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of down towns destroyed by Walmart, or the thousands of desolate factories, to know this is true.

We are all dependent on what goes on beyond our horizons. And we look to other people, those above us, those around us, to keep track of what those things are. We have to.

This dependency is a socially necessary thing. Society could not exist without it. A worker who was more concerned with the affairs across the planet simply could not give enough attention to be able to manage his own life. The same for the small business man. He must attend to his business, his community, the people he buys from and sells to. He doesn’t really have the time to spend a lot of it worrying about the larger issues.

And of course there are other dependencies. We are dependent on the behavior of our neighbors, on the politicians who are expected to serve us, on the people who provide the public services in our community. Society is a web of dependencies. So the question is: Do these dependencies carry any obligation beyond the purely economic? Do they carry a moral obligation?

And what do we mean by moral obligation? From “The Free Dictionary:”http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/moral+obligation we have: MORAL OBLIGATION. A duty which one owes, and which he ought to perform, but which he is not legally bound to fulfill.

Now some of these dependencies are equal exchanges. I depend on my neighbors, and my neighbors depend on me. The sense of ‘duty which one owes,’ seems clear in these cases. It is not so clear in cases of hierarchy. Does a boss owe his employee anything besides his salary? Is not the entire value for both parties of the relationship summed up in the exchange of labor for money? Is not the employee compensated in his wages for all the factors of his employment including, say, the fact that he can be fired at will? If we believe this, then be believe that not only is the labor market efficient, but that it is just. But if we believe a particular market is just, how can we believe that the same market, tilted by external forces, is also just? Is the market produced by a monopoly just? And employment, we have a market defined not only by an asymmetry of needs, as are all markets, but by an asymmetry of information. Can the employee negotiate a premium on not only on what he doesn’t know, but what he doesn’t know he doesn’t know? Not only can he not negotiate such a premium, but it is unreasonable to expect him to. And even were he to, he would be in competition with those who would not demand such a premium.

The point here there is that there is a gap, which cannot be remedied by formal debt and application of law.

And what about the relationship between the wealthy and the rest of us. Let us first admit the obvious. They pretty much control the economy. That is, our welfare, the welfare of the society is dependent on their actions. Even if this were not completely the case, it is very much so. By their actions, should they choose, they can do enormous damage to society.

I am not claiming conspiracy. I merely claim a similar response to similar motivations. There was no conspiracy to outsourcing, nor is there to robotization, but damage was done, though some would say the benefits to society more than compensated for it.

But who got compensated? Did the workers who lost their jobs to outsourcing gain any share of the increased profits enjoyed by those companies who sent their jobs overseas? Were they owed any? Did the companies who fired these workers for greater profit elsewhere have any obligation to these workers, or society in general? Or just to enjoy their increased profits, to divide among the wealthy shareholders?



So do the wealthy owe the rest of us anything? It need not be a matter of owing. A parent has obligation to his offspring. But it is not a matter of debt. And in a very real sense we count on the wealthy to take care of us, to manage the economy for the benefit of us all. Why should society allow them to have and retain wealth, if it were not to the benefit of the rest of society? If the wealthy have no obligation, then they have no obligation to act to society’s benefit. They have no obligation not to inflict damage on the rest of society. So if inflicting damage on society profits them, then we should expect them to do so.


Unless they indeed have a moral obligation to the society which supports them.

Friday, September 26, 2014

Income Growth During the Latest Expansion



Check this out:



The article is titled “This Really Depressing Graph about the Economy is Turning Heads.”  Which it should.  I share it here with you.  The source is Pavlina Tcherneva, who is an economist at Bard College, in Annandale-on-Hudson, New York, and the Levy Economics Institute, a think tank associated with the college, using data from Piketty and Saez.  Basically it shows the wealthy’s control of the economy increasing until now the growth of their wealth and income is obtained by plundering the rest of the economy, which is to say us, the rest of the people.  The graph charts increase in income, but you better believe the rich are getting richer, at our expense, we are getting poorer.  Not much of a recovery, this latest, when it is gotten for a few by preying on the many.

Thanks, Yahoo, for the pointer, on Sept. 25, 2014. 

Thursday, February 27, 2014

Graphs on Inome Inequality


A graph that has been doing the rounds, lately.
And here:
And here:


 The source is:

The World Top Incomes Database:

This is my own version, taken from an EXCEL download of the relevant data, the graph drawn using the EXCEL graphics wizard, (since I couldn’t figure how to copy the graph itself directly to my website.)  All data includes capital gains, which for the bottom 90% isn’t much.  All data is for the United States.



Note that the .01% are doing really well. Their average income is currently at almost $22 Million.  So well, in fact, that we have to redraw the graph with out the top two brackets get some sort of perspective:



With this graph, we can see that the top 10 - 5% bracket have made some progress since oh, say 1985, say,  and the top 5 - 1% a little more.  And the other two brackets have done quite nicely, though, as Washington says, peanuts and chump change respectively compared to the .01%.  If we look at the bottom 90% however, it seems as if their glory days are in the past.  From 1941 or so to 1975 their income more than tripled.  It has remained largely static since then, however, and since the 2007 recession has declined about 15% from its peak. 

Of course, looking at the graph of the top percentages, we could say: “Hey, that’s the income of just a few.  There’s still plenty to go around for the rest of us.”  

But let’s look at that.  Here’s the Share of Total Income for the top percentiles, starting at the top 10%., which we see now take home about 50% of the country’s personal income. (To recover the brackets in the above graphs, take the difference between two adjacent curves.  Thus, the top 10 – 5 % bracket is the difference between the top line and the magenta line, about 12% in 2012, the 5 – 1% bracket the difference between the next two lines, in 2012 about 15%, etc.)   


As is clearer in the next graph, the top 1%  pull in about 23% of the nation’s total personal income.  This is up from a low of about 9% in the late 1970’s. The top .01%, that is the richest 30,000 people or so, in 2012 took down over 5% of the nation’s personal income, up from less than 2% in 1980.

Looking at it share-wise, one person’s share is a share denied another. So where in 1979 the bottom 99% of the population shared 91% of the nation’s production, in 2012 they shared only 77%.  If we consider just the bottom 90% of the population, in 1979 they shared 67% of the nation’s production.  In 2012  the bottom 90%  shared less than 50%. That's a 17% decrease in their share of the nation's production.     But to them, it's a 30% decrease in their income.  That is, instead of $30,000 per year, the bottom 90% would be averaging over $40,000 per year.  

The question for the second 9% is are they doing better than they would it the top 1% had not absconded with so many of the gains.  The answer may be no, and even if it is yes, they have to realize that much of those gains were at the expense of the 90%.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Links on the rich, taxes, education 11-04-26

Here are some links:

http://www.altweeklies.com/aan/9-things-the-rich-dont-want-you-to-know-about-taxes/Story?oid=3971382

Progressive taxes are unfair?

http://crookedtimber.org/2011/04/25/the-flip-side-of-noble-lie-side-economics/#more-19786

James Kroeger's comments offer an interesting argument: The rich are no richer even though they're richer. Because they're richer they drive the price of everything rich people like up, so there's no real gain in it for them. He argues therefore, that a (proper) progressive system, without loopholes, doesn't change the actual purchasing power of anybody. I don't think it is quite true, because the flip side of the argument is the poor are no poorer even though they're poorer. Because they're poorer the price of everything they need goes down, so there's no real loss to them. Mmm... Something else is going on... Still, worth the read.


This is a review of Hacker and Pierson’s book “Winner-Take-All Politics”

http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2010/09/hacker_and_pierson_inequality

Here’s a fun little tax toy, but not to be taken too seriously, as nobody who makes $10 Million pays 36.3% of his income on taxes. (As we have shown elsewhere, http://anamecon.blogspot.com/2010/10/what-income-of-top-1-means-to-rest-of.html the rich pay on average about 17%.)

http://www.wheredidmytaxdollarsgo.com/

This is a piece on the financial problems besetting the nation’s public universities, particularly discussing the University of California.

http://realignmentproject.wordpress.com/2009/07/23/the-balance-wheel-of-social-machinery-universal-public-higher-education/

Part of the problem here, which I mentioned somewhere else, is the equalization of factor prices due to free trade, which eventually propagates throughout an entire economy. However, those sectors of an economy more exposed to international competition ‘equalize’ faster, most labor in particular. This implies that those sectors more insulated from international competition rise relative to the exposed sectors. (The exposed sectors are, in real terms, declining. Since this does not appear so much nominally to be the case, a great deal must be accounted for by hidden inflation. We should not be surprised then, at the steady increase in gasoline prices.) This accounts for part of the relative rise in costs of public education in particular, and government in general, as the tax base is eroded by declining wages, which are converging to the wages of developing countries, like China.

How economists can consider this a good thing entirely escapes me. Well, not entirely. This also accounts for part of the relative rise in health care costs. It also helps account for some of the housing bubble, the price collapse due to lack of demand due to decreased earnings by labor.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Things are Worse than they Look

Here are a couple of neat pointers: The first goes to a article at a good blog, which points to an interactive feature at the EPI (Economic Policy Institute) website.

http://crookedtimber.org/2011/02/10/income-growth-shares-over-time/

A commenter at CT links to:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akVL7QY0S8A

a lecture by Elizabeth Warren titled: “The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class: Higher Risks, Lower Rewards, and a Shrinking Safety Net.” This is a good and informative lecture. Well worth the time.